New York’s Personal Injury Protection (PIP) system plays a central role in the state’s no-fault auto insurance framework. Insurers provide fast medical benefits and lost wages to accident victims without requiring proof of fault. Fraudsters exploit this setup aggressively. Claims process billions annually, and fraud siphons off substantial funds — driving up premiums for every honest policyholder in the state.
The Landscape of NY PIP Fraud
PIP fraud in New York falls into several distinct categories:
Staged Accidents Deliberate collisions involving multiple cooperating parties, often orchestrated by fraud rings. These generate inflated injury claims across multiple PIP policies simultaneously.
Provider Mills Medical clinics (often controlled by non-physicians or fraud rings) that bill for unnecessary, excessive, or outright fabricated treatments. NY’s fee schedule makes this especially lucrative.
Attorney-Runner Schemes Recruiters direct accident victims to specific attorneys and clinics in exchange for payment — a violation of both insurance and professional ethics rules.
Soft Tissue Claim Inflation Real accidents, inflated injuries. Claimants exaggerate or extend soft tissue complaints to maximize medical billing and lost wage payments.
The TPA’s Role in Fighting Fraud
TPAs sit at the center of the claims process, making them uniquely positioned to detect and disrupt fraud before it becomes a paid loss.
Early Red Flag Recognition
Effective fraud defense starts at FNOL. Key early indicators include:
- Multiple claimants from a single vehicle with identical injuries
- Accident locations in known fraud corridors (specific ZIP codes in Queens, Brooklyn, Bronx)
- Claimants directed to the same attorney or clinic immediately after loss
- Loss dates that coincide with policy inception or renewal
- Delays in reporting inconsistent with the severity described
AI-Powered Pattern Detection
Modern SIU platforms use machine learning to surface fraud networks that human review would never catch. When three claimants from different accidents share the same clinic, attorney, and treatment timeline, the system flags all three for coordinated review — not just the individual file.
Timely Examinations Under Oath (EUOs)
In New York, the EUO is one of the most powerful tools available. Properly noticed and conducted EUOs toll the 30-day payment clock, give adjusters sworn testimony to work with, and frequently result in uncooperative claimants abandoning fraudulent claims.
The key is speed — EUOs must be scheduled promptly and followed through. TPAs with established vendor relationships can mobilize this process within days of FNOL.
Independent Medical Examinations (IMEs)
IMEs are critical for contesting exaggerated or fabricated injuries. Scheduled early, with qualified physicians familiar with NY no-fault law, they provide the medical evidence needed to support denial and withstand arbitration.
Building a Fraud Mitigation Culture
The best fraud defense isn’t just technology — it’s a culture where every adjuster, from first contact to closure, understands what fraud looks like and has clear escalation paths.
This means:
- Regular fraud trend briefings for adjuster teams
- Clear SIU referral criteria (not vague “if you suspect fraud”)
- Fast-loop feedback when referrals result in denials or recoveries
- Coordination with NICB, NYPD, and the NY AG’s office when warranted
The ROI of Taking Fraud Seriously
For every dollar invested in proactive PIP fraud detection, TPAs and carriers routinely see multiples in return — from denied claims, reduced litigation, and subrogation recovery. More importantly, demonstrating a strong anti-fraud posture affects premiums, retentions, and reinsurance pricing.
In New York’s PIP environment, fraud isn’t a background problem — it’s a front-line operational challenge that demands a dedicated, coordinated response.
Aegis One Inc. maintains dedicated fraud detection workflows and SIU referral pipelines for every claim we administer. Learn how we protect your book →
Ready to modernize your claims operation?
Schedule a free consultation and see what AI-powered claims administration looks like in practice.